Knut R . Wangen Some Fundamental Problems in Becker , Grossman and Murphy ' s Implementation of Rational Addiction Theory
نویسنده
چکیده
The econometric implementation of rational addiction theory has been highly influenced by Becker, Grossman and Murphy (BGM). They specify an Euler equation where current consumption is determined by current price and past and future consumption. This model is claimed to be able to discriminate between rational addictive, myopic addictive, and non-addictive behavior. However, as demonstrated in this paper, the coefficients of the Euler equation are not structural parameters. Provided that two implausible assumptions do not hold, the Euler equation coefficients for the rational addict are shown to be non-constant. But even when these assumptions are assumed to be valid, the coefficients of the Euler equation will vary under the alternative hypothesis of myopic addiction. Moreover, and in contrast to the common interpretation, BGM's non-addicted consumer is influenced by past consumption, implying that a rational and a myopic non-addict behave differently. These problems makes it unclear how analyses based on the BGM approach can support, or reject, rational addiction theory.
منابع مشابه
Rational Choice Theory: A Cultural Reconsideration
Economists have heralded the formulation of the expected utility theorem as a universal method of choice under uncertainty. In their seminal paper, Stigler and Becker (Stigler & Becker, 1977) declared that “human behavior can be explained by a generalized calculus of utility-maximizing behavior” (p.76). The universality of the rational choice theory has been widely criticized by psychologists, ...
متن کاملA neuroeconomic theory of rational addiction and nonlinear time-perception.
Neuroeconomic conditions for "rational addiction" (Becker & Murphy 1988) have been unknown. This paper derived the conditions for "rational addiction" by utilizing a nonlinear time-perception theory of "hyperbolic" discounting, which is mathematically equivalent to the q-exponential intertemporal choice model based on Tsallis' statistics. It is shown that (i) Arrow-Pratt measure for temporal co...
متن کاملOn the Use of Panel Data Methods to Estimate Rational Addiction Models
This paper reviews some of the econometrics problems faced when estimating a rational addiction model of Becker and Murphy (1988) using panel data. This is illustrated with three empirical applications. The rst application looks at cigarette consumption using macro panel data on American states over time (see Baltagi and Gri¢ n (2001)). The second application looks at liquor consumption using ...
متن کاملNature or Nurture? An Analysis of Rational Addiction to Mobile Social Applications
Through the lens of rational addiction theory (Becker and Murphy, 1988), this study investigates whether addiction to mobile social apps should be viewed as a rational behavior rather than an uncontrollable, irrational disorder. To derive the analytical model, this study extends the rational addiction framework to include a utility-level network effect as the key factor that regulates the inter...
متن کاملEvaluating Cigarette Demand Models
In the past 15 years there has been a substantial increase in the taxation of cigarettes in the United States. The federal government and most state governments have increased taxes on cigarettes in an effort to reduce smoking. In the period 1990-2003, the national average price of cigarettes increased by 85%. This paper will use data from 1990-2003 to examine the effect that these large price ...
متن کامل